
Last night, my wife and I watched the two-hour Saddleback Civil Forum with John McCain and Barack Obama, hosted by pastor Rick Warren on CNN HD (Still waiting for Fox News or MSNBC to have a HD channel.)
To start, I was extremely impressed by not only each candidate, but the entire debate and format. One of the biggest complaints about typical debates is that the candidates come off with scripted answers, and have questions tailored toward them, which may allow for a greater degree of bias depending on which questions are asked to each candidate.
In addition, when Obama answered the questions in the first hour, McCain was kept in the dark in the "cone of silence" as to not give McCain any advantage in hearing the questions or Obama's answers. While I didn't hear it mentioned, I'm under the assumption that the candidates did not know the questions to be asked beforehand, especially considering the on the fly answers given, rather than a boring scripted campaign commercial like we'll most likely see in the upcoming debates.
The picture above with both McCain and Obama was a genuinely nice moment with the candidates, and emphasized a positive message, rather than the attacks being purported by both sides and candidates.
Here are some thoughts from the various answers each candidate gave:
Three Wisest People
Obama mentioned his wife, his grandmother, and then a various number of politicians he's worked with over the years. McCain listed General David Petraeus, Democrat John Lewis (a civil rights leader and Obama supporter,) and former Ebay CEO Meg Whitman. Obama played the safe answer on this one, while McCain covered all bases, and gave the better answer simply for mentioning Petraeus.
Most Gut Wrenching Decision
I don't recall Obama's answer, but I was successfully able to predict (to my non-political wife's amazement) exactly what McCain would say. While not accepting preferential treatment as a P.O.W. in Vietnam, I wonder if McCain has beat this into our heads too much and the average Americans are sick of mentioning it, or if political junkies like myself are being overwhelmed with the 24/7 news coverage. Something I'm guessing we're all tired of hearing is McCain mentioning the phrase "my friends" to the point where my wife (again, non-political) was verbally counting the number of times he mentioned it. I think she stopped counting after it was said ten times.
Abortion
The one gaffe from Obama during the forum. By mentioning it was above his pay grade it came off as avoiding the question for political expediency, although he did acknowledge his pro-choice views directly after, perhaps as an attempt to correct the earlier avoidance. McCain was very simple in stating that life starts at conception, as do human rights.
Marriage
Both candidates seemed to have similar answers by defining marriage as between one man and one woman. McCain said he would only support a constitutional amendment if the government tried to force states like his own to accept the rulings of other states such as Massachusetts. Obama was more focused on civil unions.
Supreme Court Justices
This was an issue where both candidates were polar opposites. Obama claimed he would not have nominated Justices Thomas, Scalia and even Roberts. McCain predictably mentioned Ginsburg, Breyer, Souter and Stevens. This simply showed the differences of conservatives being strict constitutionalists with the more liberal members believing the Constitution is a living document.
Merit Pay for Teachers
Both candidates support a merit pay system, with Obama trying not to alienate the support of the NEA by mentioning on multiple occasions to work with the teachers on developing the system. McCain was a bit harsher claiming that good teachers would receive a bonus and bad teachers would find a different line of work, while also praising other options like charter and home schools.
Taxes
Obama referred to anyone as making under $150,000 per year as middle or lower class, thus to receive a tax break and anyone making over $250,000 per year as upper class, receiving a tax increase. The $150,000 - $250,000 range wasn't mentioned which was a bit confusing as to what would happen to those folks, or where they were classified. McCain mentioned that being rich isn't about a certain number, but rather having a house, a good job and an education. When pressed, he made his gaffe of the night by (albeit jokingly) claiming that the rich made $5 million per year in income, then conceding it would be turned into an attack ad. I am closer to that of Obama's definition of rich, but agree with McCain's policies in not increasing the tax burden on anyone in a form of economic redistribution.
Why Do You Want to be President?
Obama mentioned that the American dream was "slipping away" and he wanted to bring folks together. McCain wanted to inspire people to do things for others than themselves, and also bring folks together.
Overall, both candidates performed very well in this setting. McCain doesn't have the charisma that Obama does, but was better at directly answering the questions as Obama seemed to play the role of typical politician by avoiding answering a question or changing the scope of the question and answering a different question than presented. While there were many religious themed questions, as would be expected at an evangelical forum, but as shown above, I wasn't really interested in those, but more on specific issues and policies as I feel most Americans are interested in.